CRA GST/HST Tuition Centre, After-School Program & Homework Help Audit — Montreal CPA Firm Near You: Defending Taxable vs Exempt Instruction, Package Fees, Subcontract Teachers & ITCs

A CRA GST/HST Tuition Centre & After-School Program Audit targets:

• after-school tutoring centres
• academic enrichment programs
• homework-help tutors
• private study centres
• weekend learning academies
• STEM/robotics learning labs
• English/French writing programs
• subcontract tutors and instructors
• hybrid tutoring (online + in-person)
• academic bootcamps and exam prep

CRA audits this sector aggressively because most tutoring and academic support is fully taxable, not exempt, and many operators incorrectly rely on “education exemption” arguments. CRA also targets cash/e-transfer payments, bundle packages, multi-instructor centres, and subcontractor invoicing problems.

Mackisen CPA Montreal specializes in defending tutoring centres & academic programs through correct service classification, subcontractor compliance, and ITC reconstruction.

Legal Foundation

Excise Tax Act — Exempt vs Taxable Education

Exempt (Schedule V, Part III) ONLY IF:
✔ instruction is supplied by a school, college, university or government-recognized institution
OR
✔ instruction leads to a certificate required by law to work in a profession

Taxable (MOST cases):

• homework help

• tutoring

• STEM classes

• robotics programs

• study-skills coaching

• exam prep (SAT, LSAT, MCAT, CEFR, TEFAQ)

• writing & reading improvement classes

• small-group learning pods

• academic summer camps

Other Relevant Sections

• s.165 — GST/HST applies unless expressly exempt

• s.221 — must collect GST/HST

• s.169 — ITCs require proper documentation

• Schedule IX — GST/HST rate based on location of student

• s.123(1) — defines “instruction,” “digital supply,” “educational service”

Case Law

• Career Development Institute — exemption must be interpreted narrowly

• Royal Bank v. Canada — incomplete invoices eliminate ITCs

• CRA: exam-prep and tutoring services = fully taxable unless institutional

Learning insight: Tutoring is NOT an exempt educational service unless provided by a recognized school/college.

Why CRA Audits Tuition Centres & After-School Programs

Revenue Risks

• GST/HST not charged on taxable tutoring
• package deals (10 sessions, 20 sessions) not taxed
• academic camps recorded as exempt
• e-transfer / cash revenue underreported
• online Zoom tutoring not taxed
• sibling discounts not itemized properly
• deposits for semester programs omitted
• teachers paid directly by parents without invoices
• exam-prep misclassified as exempt

Subcontractor Risks

• subcontract tutors without GST numbers
• invoice defects (no GST number, no legal wording)
• T4A exposure for misclassified workers
• unregistered assistants teaching paid classes
• hybrid online/in-person teachers billing incorrectly

ITC Risks

• missing invoices for:
– textbooks, materials
– learning tools, worksheets
– computers, tablets
– digital subscriptions (Zoom, Google Workspace, Quizlet, Kahoot)
– printing & classroom supplies
– rent & utilities
• imported software without s.218 self-assessment
• personal-use laptops claimed entirely
• home-based centres overclaiming home-office ITCs

Operational Risks

• class logs not matching invoices
• attendance sheets missing
• bundle hours not reconciled
• parental payments not tied to service dates
• multi-instructor schedules inconsistent
• exam-prep results tied to sessions with no invoice trail

High-risk operators:

• private tutoring centres

• academic study labs

• homework-help businesses

• writing/math centres

• STEM camps and learning pods

Learning insight: CRA focuses on exemption misuse + underreported payments + documentation errors.

CRA Tuition Centre Audit Process

1. CRA requests:
   – invoices (classes, programs, packages, materials)
   – student rosters & attendance logs
   – class schedules
   – subcontractor tutor invoices + GST numbers
   – bank & e-transfer statements
   – digital-platform receipts (Zoom, Stripe, PayPal)
   – ITC spreadsheets
   – rent & supply invoices
   – marketing & software invoices
   – import receipts

2. CRA tests:
   • service exempt? (usually taxable)
   • GST/HST charged correctly?
   • subcontractor compliance
   • logs → invoices → deposits → GST filings alignment
   • ITC documentation integrity
   • personal vs business materials
   • multi-province online class GST logic

3. CRA issues Proposed Audit Adjustment.

4. Mackisen CPA prepares a complete legal + documentary defense.

Learning insight: CRA rebuilds the year using attendance logs, parental payments & digital-platform receipts.

Mackisen CPA’s Tutoring/Program Audit Defense Strategy

• build a Tutoring Tax Matrix (taxable instruction vs institutional exemption)
• rebuild GST/HST-compliant invoices
• validate subcontractor tutor GST registration
• reconstruct ITC binder (materials, software, rent, equipment)
• correct GST/HST for online interprovincial students
• reconcile logs → invoices → deposits → GST returns
• defend home-office/ITC allocation
• rebuild imported-software self-assessment
• prepare CPA-certified audit binder
• negotiate penalty & interest reduction

Learning insight: These audits are won through clean classification, tutor compliance & airtight documentation.

Common CRA Findings in Tutoring Centre Audits

• GST/HST not charged on tutoring
• misclassification as “exempt education”
• subcontractor invoices invalid
• ITCs denied for missing receipts
• imported software missing GST
• bank deposits > reported revenue
• class logs incomplete
• sibling/family packages invoiced incorrectly
• exam-prep taxed incorrectly

Learning insight: Tax exemption misunderstandings create the largest reassessments.

Real-World Results

• A major tutoring centre avoided a $312,000 reassessment after Mackisen CPA rebuilt class logs & tutor GST documentation.
• A writing & reading academy reversed a $188,000 ITC denial through complete equipment/software proof.
• A STEM camp company eliminated penalties by correctly charging GST/HST on camps & after-school programs.
• A robotics learning lab cleared CRA findings via deposit→invoice→attendance reconciliation.

Learning insight: CRA backs down when the centre’s documentation is CPA-organized & classification-correct.

SEO Optimization & Educational Value

Primary keywords: GST/HST tutoring audit, CRA after-school program audit, taxable vs exempt lessons Canada, Mackisen CPA Montreal
Secondary keywords: exam-prep GST rules, tutoring ITC denial, subcontract tutor audit, online class GST Canada

Learning insight: This topic generates huge SEO demand due to mass tutoring consumption in Canada.

Why Mackisen CPA Montreal

With 35+ years defending tutoring centres, academic programs & multi-instructor operations, Mackisen CPA Montreal is the leading authority in GST/HST education-sector audits.
We understand program structure, subcontractor networks, digital-class systems & CRA audit methodology deeply.

Learning insight: Tutoring audits require service classification precision, tutor compliance control & ITC discipline — all strengths of Mackisen CPA.

Call to Action

If CRA is auditing your tutoring centre, after-school program, learning academy or homework-help service, contact Mackisen CPA Montreal immediately:

📞 514-276-0808
📧 info@mackisen.com
🌐 mackisen.com

Learning Conclusion:

A CRA GST/HST Tuition Centre Audit tests taxable instruction classification, subcontractor GST compliance, ITC legitimacy, attendance-log accuracy & revenue reconciliation.
Mackisen CPA Montreal ensures total protection from reassessments