CRA GAAR / Aggressive Planning Audit — Montreal CPA Firm Near You: Substance Over Form

A CRA GAAR (General Anti-Avoidance Rule) Audit is among the most serious corporate tax investigations in Canada. It targets transactions that may technically comply with the Income Tax Act but are seen by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) or Revenue Québec as abusive, artificial, or lacking genuine commercial substance. Mackisen CPA Montreal provides legal-grade audit representation to ensure your corporate reorganization, tax structure, or investment strategy stands up under GAAR review.

Legal Foundation

Law: Income Tax Act s.245 — empowers CRA to disregard or recharacterize transactions that constitute abusive tax avoidance.
Jurisprudence: Canada Trustco Mortgage Co. v. Canada (2005 SCC) — establishes the three-step GAAR test: (1) a tax benefit, (2) an avoidance transaction, and (3) misuse or abuse of the Act’s provisions.

Why You Need a CPA for a GAAR or Aggressive Planning Audit

GAAR audits require more than bookkeeping—they require legal reasoning, economic substance analysis, and strong documentation. CRA investigators evaluate intent and structure, often consulting the GAAR Committee before issuing reassessments. A single misstep in disclosure or communication can trigger major penalties or criminal referrals.

Mackisen CPA Montreal works with leading tax lawyers to build documentation that clearly demonstrates legitimate business purpose, commercial reality, and adherence to the law’s object and spirit.

Learning insight: GAAR is not about what you did—it’s about why you did it. A CPA ensures that your intent and documentation align with lawful tax planning, not avoidance.

What Mackisen CPA’s GAAR Audit Defense Includes

• Complete review of the transaction series under the three-step GAAR framework.

• Legal and accounting analysis of each transaction’s purpose and economic effect.

• Preparation of an evidence binder proving business substance and reasonable expectations of profit.

• Drafting of detailed response letters to CRA’s GAAR Committee.

• Coordination with tax counsel for advanced rulings or settlement discussions.

Learning insight: CRA can’t disallow what it understands. Clear explanation of commercial logic can end a GAAR audit before it becomes a court case.

Common Triggers for GAAR Audits

• Complex reorganizations with tax-free rollovers under s.85 or s.87.

• Surplus-stripping or pipeline transactions using s.84.1 or s.55.

• Aggressive tax shelters or circular cash-flow schemes.

• Hybrid-debt, double-deduction, or avoidance of withholding taxes.

• Repeated transactions lacking independent business rationale.

Mackisen CPA identifies potential GAAR risk early and repositions your file with full transparency, demonstrating that every transaction serves a real commercial purpose.

How Mackisen CPA Manages GAAR Investigations

1. Conducts forensic review of all relevant agreements, valuations, and correspondences.

2. Prepares a written analysis comparing your structure to accepted case law.

3. Engages CRA’s GAAR Division proactively to explain transaction substance.

4. Files objections and appeals when GAAR reassessments misapply intent or legislative purpose.

5. Implements future-proof documentation standards for continued compliance.

Learning insight: CRA’s GAAR division operates on the principle of substance over form. A CPA-guided audit defense shows that your structure achieves real business efficiency, not mere tax advantage.

Benefits of Professional GAAR Audit Representation

• Prevents aggressive tax planning from being misinterpreted as avoidance.

• Reduces risk of 25–50% gross-negligence penalties.

• Demonstrates transparency and intent to comply.

• Builds credibility with auditors, minimizing litigation exposure.

• Strengthens your long-term tax structure for future transactions.

Learning insight: When you can explain your tax strategy in plain business terms, it becomes legitimate. A CPA helps you articulate that clarity before the government makes assumptions.

SEO Optimization and Learning Value

Primary Keywords: CRA GAAR Audit, Aggressive Tax Planning Montreal, CPA Firm Near You, CRA Audit Defense, Revenue Québec GAAR Audit, Corporate Tax Representation, Canada Trustco GAAR, Mackisen CPA Montreal.
Secondary Keywords: CRA abusive tax avoidance, CRA recharacterization, GAAR committee response, corporate reorganization audit, CRA section 245 audit.

Learning insight: CRA’s GAAR division focuses on intent. Mackisen CPA focuses on integrity. The clearer your documentation, the stronger your defense.

Real Client Success

• A holding company preserved a $1.8M tax deferral after Mackisen CPA proved legitimate business purpose behind its share reorganization.

• A family trust avoided GAAR reassessment on an estate freeze after our team demonstrated long-term succession and non-tax motives.

• A cross-border firm successfully defended its structure before the GAAR Committee by submitting OECD-aligned transfer-pricing and commercial reasoning.

Why Mackisen CPA Montreal

With over 35 years of combined experience in tax defense, Mackisen CPA Montreal bridges accounting precision with legal argumentation. Our team works seamlessly with tax counsel to ensure every restructuring, sale, and investment aligns with the Income Tax Act’s intent and judicial interpretation.

Learning insight: GAAR audits test not only compliance—but credibility. Mackisen CPA transforms complex transactions into transparent, lawful strategies backed by evidence.

Learning conclusion: The CRA’s GAAR power is broad—but reason and evidence prevail. With Mackisen CPA Montreal, substance and strategy become your shield against misinterpretation.